Welcome back to my ‘Things I don’t love’ series where we discuss products that didn’t work for me or that I just haven’t loved.
I purchased two matte palettes from MUA at this time in 2015. I hadn’t tried any eyeshadows from MUA at the time so I wasn’t sure what to expect but I had read many good reviews so I had high hopes. The two palettes that I picked up are the Ever After Matte Palette and the Winter Forest Matte Collection and I have to say that I don’t love either of these palettes.
Firstly, the packaging is quite cheap looking and is extremely basic in style. There is no mirror provided and these palettes come with 10 shadows. On a positive note, both palettes have a sticker on the back that provide shade names, which I do like. Another pro is that these are very compact.
Looking at the Ever After Matte Palette first, you can see that the shades are very neutral and there are a number of shades in the palette that look quite similar – particularly the shades in the top row and the first two browns in the second row. Annoying!
The Winter Forest Matte Collection has an unusual range of colours but I can see how this was curated for ‘winter.’ Again, the pigmentation is extremely hit and miss – either quite poor or staining. The two grey shades (Smoke and Dove Grey) make my eyes look tired and bruised so I never use these shades. Also, the dark blue (Midnight) and the teal colour (Aqua), really do stain so if you don’t use a primer these are hard to blend and difficult to remove.
The formula of these shadows is consistent across these two palettes so I am going to make a few general points:
- The texture of these shadows in general is very dry.
- Some of them are very densely packed into the pan so they also feel very hard to the touch.
- The dry texture converts to a crumbly, dusty powder when you tap in your brush.
- The pigmentation is really not great and you can see in the swatches that these shadows can be quite patchy (I made an effort to blend these out smoothly as they were so very dusty/crumbly).
- It is sort of a weird situation of having the shadows either blend away to nothing OR having them be so dark that they kind of stain and are hard to blend.
I feel like these shadows appear to be much better quality in the swatches here than they are in real life. I never reach for these palettes because I just don’t enjoy these shadows at all. I feel like I can build and build some of the mid-toned crease shades and just don’t seem to get anywhere pigmentation wise – with a brush they just don’t seem to transfer well to the lids, even with a primer.
Overall, I can’t recommend these matte palettes from MUA. I know that people really rate the MAU eyeshadow palettes but these really haven’t worked for me. In my opinion if you want a great budget-friendly, cruelty-free matte eyeshadow palette, the Freedom Makeup London Pro 12 Audacious Matte palette is excellent and I believe it is the same price! You can read my review of the Pro 12 Audacious Matte palette here for more information.
Have a fantastic day!